You Pick

I was playing in the house centre this morning with my students. This is always fun! The following scenario made me laugh:
S lays out two outfits for her "baby" to wear.
S: Mrs. R, which one should my baby wear?
Me: (pointing to one) I like that one.
Pause.
S: (pointing to the other one) I'm just gonna say you pick this one.
Pause.
Me: (trying not to laugh) I appreciate your honesty.